Wednesday, November 21, 2007

Are Those Who Question 9/11 Anti-Semites?

Anti-semitism is one of the most frequent allegations levied by defenders of the government's version of 9/11 against people questioning that account.

Is it true? Are 9/11 activists really anti-semites?

Well, prominent Rabbi Michael Lerner and other Jewish leaders are calling for 9/11 truth. Indeed, Rabbi Lerner says that uncovering the truth of 9/11 has the power to bring positive, lasting change to our nation and to our world.

And many of the leading members of Scholars for 9/11 Truth and Justice, Architects and Engineers for 9/11 Truth, and other groups questioning 9/11 are Jewish. As are some of the other prominent individuals who have called for a deeper investigation into the events of 9/11. Indeed, some of the most-committed and hard-working 9/11 activists, such as Jon Gold and many others, are Jewish.

Moreover, the charges of anti-semitism are clearly illogical. For example, a book has been labelled as anti-semitic even though its co-editor is Jewish and it contains contributions from 4 Jewish writers.

So that must mean that these are "self-loathing" Jews, right? No, actually. I know many of these people quite well, and they are wholly comfortable being Jewish. Many are proud of their heritage and their faith.

As former Secretary of State Colin Powell once stated, “It is not anti-Semitic to criticize the policies of the state of Israel.” Presumably, criticizing illegal acts by Mossad or other Israeli services would also be acceptable.

Therefore, there is nothing wrong with having a debate based upon whether or not there are credible facts justifying the hypothesis that portions of the 9/11 attacks were subcontracted out by rogue elements within the U.S. government to people associated with Mossad or other Israeli intelligence services, just as it is reasonable to discuss whether or not there are facts implicating British or other allied intelligence services in aiding and abetting the attacks.

There are admittedly a very small number of people claiming that they are for 9/11 truth but making anti-semitic remarks. However, they are shunned by the overwhelming majority of 9/11 activists who abhor anti-semitism. People who say "the Jews did it" and then use a bunch of anti-semitic and derogatory language are probably government infiltrators. Again, however, debating factual evidence one way or the other concerning the possible involvement of people affiliated with an allied intelligence service -- British or Israeli -- is not anti-semitic ... it is Constitutionally-protected free speech.




8 Comments:

Blogger www.Edmonton911Truth.com said...

Doing activism up here in cold country Canada I've experienced that cold shoulder by people who accuse me as either a Jew hater or anti Semitic...(NOT TRUE) This comes with a longer list of names such as "You are a war criminal helping the enemy", You hate or soldiers traitor"(NOT TRUE EITHER)...Fortunately this is a seldom occurrence as I'm mostly met with positive encounters. It concerns me here (In Canada) the anti Semitic card people carelessly play because of the unjustly hate laws in Canada that has chipped away our freedom of speech. Today I took the opportunity to use this repressive law to see if our government stands by it or not....Glenn Beck of CNN has attacked the 9/11 movement as terrorists , Muslim community and Mexican community on national TV that pushes the hate laws envelope here in Canada ....I started a CRTC initiative today with hopes to take BECK off the Canadian airwaves....CRTC is like your FCC that governs the public airwaves... We'll keep an eye on the results.

1:42 PM  
Blogger www.Edmonton911Truth.com said...

I posted your article on my web site www.edmonton911truth.com
Hope your ok by this...Doug

1:46 PM  
Blogger JB Campbell said...

If you deny your "anti-Semitism" you play into their hands. As we know, the Arabs are the Semites. The Jews from Russia are the anti-Semites. They are not Semitic and they never claim to be. They call their enemies "anti-Semites" because of the clinical and sinister SOUND, which they try to make SOUND like mental illness. Calling their enemies "anti-Semitic" also SUGGESTS that they have some Semitic right to invade Palestine. Coming from Russia, of course, they are just pretenders. That's why the few Sephardic (Semitic) Jews in Israel are second-class citizens, because they at least have the right to live in Semiteland. Russian Jews are embarrassed by these people, who are indistinguishable from Palestinians except for their horrible "religion."

Arabs should be encouraged to take the Jewish weapon away from them and claim to be the only victims of anti-Semitism.

We must be anti-Jewish in every way. You can be anti-Semitic if you don't like Arabs, but the Jews are our only real enemies.

2:55 PM  
Blogger Davol White said...

I'm into 9/11 Truth, but can't boast of being Jewish to exempt myself from antisemitism. I figure I was rooting for the semitic ones last year when I was cheering on Hezbolah after that rude country next door illegally invaded. No, I'm not antisemitic, but thoes white European people who settled in Israel really offend my respect for human rights. Calling me names won't change that opinion. I got some names for you. Nazi is as Nazi does.

3:26 PM  
Blogger pcapostate said...

Davol White,

Let us not forget that a Nazi didn't own the WTCs, but a Jew named Silverstein did.

Let us not forget that five Nazis werenh't arrested on 9-11-2001 for filming the impacts and dancing in the street, but five Israeli Jews were.

Let us not forget that Nazis do not monopolize the Mainstream Media apparatusm but ethnic Jews do. [http://www.natall.com/who-rules-america]

Let us not forget that the head of our Homeland Security department, Michael Chertoff, is not a Nazi, but he is an ethnic Jew, whose fathyer was a Rabbi and who shares dual citizenship with Israel.

Let us not forget that our current Attorney General, the man that advocates torture, Michael Mukasey is not a Nazi, but is in fact a Jew.

Let us not forget that Congresses general council [head attorney] Irv Nathan, is not a Nazi, but he is a Jew.

Let us not forget that the US Government replaced the last Jewish chairman of the Fed Reserve with another Jew named Ben Bernanke. Neither are or ever were Nazis.

Let us not forget that one of the worlds greatest terrorists remains unknown, the mainstream Jewish media has NEVER mentioned his name, not because he's a Nazi, but because he's a Jew and a citizen of Israel His name is Asher Karni and he was arrested on Jan 2, 2004 at Denver International airport for having sold Pakistan, the worlds most unstable Islamic Republic more than 60 nuclear weapon detonators. [Google his name].

Let us not forget that it wasn't a Nazi attempting to sell a shoulder launched surface to air missile to FBI agents posing as Al Qaeda operatives, with the understanding they'd be used against American citizens, it was an American Orthodox Jew and NYC Jeweler named Yehuda Abraham. His name remained unmentioned in the media while it [the media] blamed Abrahams front man Hemant Lakhani. [Google both names].

I could go on and on, the fact of the matter is, MANY Jews WERE involved in what really happened on 9-11 and they've been able to count on the Jewish media around the world to cover this fact up.

Enron was not a Nazi corporation, neither was Ken Lay, the Enron CEO worked for the Belfer family, whom are likewise not Nazis, but are in fact Jews.

4:14 PM  
Blogger Oberststuhlherr said...

Is being anti-Kissinger the same as being "antisemitic"? Is the top management of the MSM disproportionately Jewish? Is the MSM biased toward Israel and Jewish interests? Is asking such questions antisemitic?

5 Israelis were arrested on 9/11/01 because a witness reported that they had acted in a celebratory manner upon seeing the success of the attacks. The MSM described them as "Middle Eastern men", in the midst of an orgy of anti-Islamic propaganda and finger-pointing. To this day it has never been made clear in the US MSM that these men were Israelis who later stated on Israeli TV that their purpose was to document the event. Now, a free press honoring its societal obligations would ask the obvious question: how did they know there was going to be an event to document?

To be clear, the news reports that did cover the arrests without specifying their nationality said that they had cameras trained on the WTC prior to the first impact.

Now, nobody has to tell me that it is considered antisemitic to point out that the men arrested were Israeli. I have already been told that rather forcefully.

I was kicked off of 911blogger for simply being accused of "Holocaust Denial". Notice that the only mention I made of "The Holocaust" was to refer interested participants to an alternative forum where such discussions are welcome. The mention of the Nürnberg lynchings was in reference to the entire mockery of justice. And I was not the person who introduced the subject. The reactive conditioning exposed in the moderator's reflexive response is most telling.

I find it amusing to see who is mimicking our
blacklist effort:

Remember that assassins prefer Catcher in the Rye.

But I don't expect you to understand.

5:40 PM  
Blogger Davol White said...

pcapostate, I guess you don't use the term Nazi as loosly as I do, but if the word is to have any revelance today we should get past the fact that that German socialist party is long gone. I just want to repeat the point I was making regarding Israel. Nazi is as Nazi does. I would call any country that pre-emptively invades another country that isn't attacking them "Nazi" to include America.

7:55 AM  
Blogger Kim said...

Don't forget Douglas Feith, who filtered false Israeli intelligence through his "Office of Special Plans" to the White House to justify the pre-emptive attack on Iraq (who had nothing to do with 9/11) and Dov Zakheim, under whose comptrollership $2.3 TRILLION of taxpayers money disappeared from the Pentagon, whose accounting department was conveniently destroyed on 9/11. This is the same Dov Zakheim who was officer of a corporation that makes remote controls for really big planes, like the ones that flew into the WTC on 9/11. And Donald Rumsfeld publicly announced the missing $$TRILLIONS$$ on 9/10 the day before 9/11. How convenient for Rabbi Dov. And let's not forget the Gee Dubya's brother and cousin were officers of the corporation that provided security for the WTC whose contract with the WTC expired 9/10/2001 the day before 9/11 (how convenient for them too. And that an Israeli company provided security for the airports involved in the 9/11 massacre of innocents. There's more.....

11:42 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home